The name Polite Society might be a two-edged sword for the Lafayette Square restaurant.
Co-owner Brian Schmitz said he and partner Jonathan Schoen were just trying to convey an air of pleasant behavior, particularly thinking about service. Polite Society definitely isn’t one of those stiff places where murmured conversation and dainty wiping of the lips is de rigeur. But it indeed is very pleasant, and service on this visit was good, casual – and definitely polite. (There were on my visit a table of mostly women, all wearing Serious Hats from the era of Lafayette Square’s first heyday. I suspect they came from a function nearby earlier that evening. But they were more the knocking-back-glasses-of-merlot types.)
Three high-ceilinged rooms make up the restaurant. The first houses the bar, the second is the larger of the two dining rooms, and the third, with brick walls, slightly quieter. But that’s relative; all these hard surfaces – ceilings, floors, walls, even windows and bare-top tables – that look good in restaurants don’t absorb sound waves. Especially in buildings this old, it’s a challenge. Expect some noise. As well, they’re still fine-tuning the nighttime light levels, thus the photos I show.
Diners should also expect to spend some time poring over the menu, at least on the first visit. There are lots of alluring things on it, a blessing and a curse. Slightly confusing – but increasingly common these days – are the multiple categories for what one presumes might be first courses. Appetizers, as well as Bites & Snacks, Charcuterie & Cheese and Soup & Salad all bedevil the indecisive.
We weren’t sure if the spatzle was a side or a bite, but we went with that and the deviled eggs. The spatzle? Think of it as an improvement on macaroni and cheese, with lots of creamy sauce, the nuttiness of gruyere enhanced with a very light hit of nutmeg. It was a large serving that arrived as an appetizer. It clearly could have been a side dish shared by the table – had not the main courses been very generously served as well. The dumplings themselves were tender, not rubbery but not falling apart, the whole thing enthusiastically received by the table.
Our only complaint was in our own timing with the order in which we tasted those things. Purely by chance, my pals and I all took a bite, maybe two, of the spatzle before trying the eggs. The first bite of the egg was overwhelmed by the residual from the cheesy little dumplings, this despite some water and/or some wine. It was an inadvertent mistake, but one I’d suggest avoiding. Because these deviled eggs are fantastic – rather lemony but not sour, the trout roe atop them giving a little saltiness and the fried capers lending some texture. They were good enough that we were using forks to get the extra filling used to anchor the three egg halves to the plate before we let the server take it away.
While Polite Society is not a German restaurant, another German-influenced dish popped up on a menu, chicken schnitzel. White meat of chicken wasn’t pounded thin, but firmly pressed down a few times to give a boneless chunk clad in crispy crumbs, a nice variation that to an American palate was more or less fried chicken. (It would make a killer sandwich.) Keeping an eye on things was what the menu termed an Austrian potato salad, warm discs of potato in a nice vinaigrette, plus some green salad leaves lightly dressed in a balsamic dressing, closer to sweet to contrast with the tartness of the potatoes.
And speaking of potatoes, the Potato Queen declared in favor of a bistro steak with frites. As ordered, it was medium-rare, perhaps not the most tender steak served in St. Louis that night, but adequate. More interesting, however, was the sauce served on the side. Called a sauce Foyot, an obscure offering from the classical French repertoire, it’s basically a bearnaise sauce that has concentrated meat juices stirred in to give it a little more body and oomph. Nice enough on the meat, certainly, but close to blissful when used as a dip for the fries, which clearly were housemade. The green vegetable on the plate was Brussels sprouts, heavily roasted. Not burnt, but many of the outer leaves were dark and crisp, a newer and perfectly acceptable variation. The sprout becomes a very different vegetable when it caramelizes so heavily.
Pork osso bucco, an abbreviated pork shank, moist and tender from a winy braise, charmed. A handsome variety of wee tomatoes marinated to a pleasant sharpness were a fine accent to the rich meat, the whole thing sitting on a polenta with goat cheese and just a hint of rosemary. Also a contrast to the richness was grilled red treviso, a chicory relative that brought its mild bitterness and a different chew to the whole thing. It’s a rugged, hearty dish, fine for the cool nights that we’ve been having.
A biscuit crust crowned the individual peach-blueberry cobbler, but it was put in the shade by the chocolate pretzel bread pudding. Not only is the visual presentation far more arresting than the average, a long narrow dish with a nicely irregular stretch of the pudding studded occasionally with fresh raspberries, a vanilla sauce drizzled over it, and a piece of hazelnut toffee jauntily perched center stage. Lovely to look at and arresting to taste, it’s dark chocolate, not so sweet, with one bite soft and full of the chocolate custard, another crisper, a third with just same plain chocolate. It’s the best bread pudding I’ve had in a long time, and if they take it off the menu, let’s plan to picket.
No lunch – yet – but they’re doing brunch on Saturday and Sunday, including a hash dish made with some of that pork osso bucco. Sounds good to me.
Polite Society
1293 Park Ave
314-325-2553
Dinner nightly, Brunch Sat.-Sun
Credit cards: Yes
Wheelchair access: Difficult
Smoking: No
Entrees: $15-$36
Recent Comments