Want to win a medal for the wine you just made on your back porch?
Wait until next year and enter it in the annual Missouri wine contest-your odds are very much better than at your favorite race track. After all, the state of Missouri’s wine competition ended recently, with the grape and wine program handing out awards at its own little private picnic. Of 220 entrants, 160 won medals. In other words, 73 percent took home hardware to hang on a bottle. The breakdown was 42 gold, 54 silver and 64 bronze.
Counting medals is a little like herding cats. I counted 151 (and I don’t count very well) but then realized that a very fine wine like the Stone Hill 2007 Norton from the Cross J Vineyard had won three gold medals by itself, one along with eight others wines that earned gold in the Dry Red class, one for being the best Dry Red and one for being the Best in Show. So rather than going back and recounting, and risking compounding all my errors, we’ll just play it like it lays and take a mulligan later.
The competition has come a long way. I was a judge the first time the state had a wine competition, back in the mid-1970s, and three of us–the late Millard Cohen, a real wine expert and a grand person, the food editor of the Springfield News-Leader and I, then representing the Post-Dispatch-gathered in a building next to a cattle barn on the fair grounds in Sedalia. The aroma of cow was stronger than the aroma of wine, but we muddled through and picked some winners (not wieners, winners), though one of the state’s leading winemakers made a midnight raid on the judges’ quarters and erected barriers so we could not confer with one another.
Now there are 12 judges, representing almost the entire country, and they do not go within miles of the fair grounds. Of course, the Fair no longer runs the contest, or provides ribbons to the winners, or has any connection with the wine except to display some after the fact. You’d think that John Ashcroft, who wouldn’t serve wine at the governor’s mansion, was back in power. He’s now a big-time player as an influential lobbyist in Washington, and I wonder if he serves wine to those he is trying to lobby.
But the competition has fixed rules for medals. The best will win, but so will a lot of second-best offerings. If the judges are working on a 100-point scale, anything above 85 may be a gold. So nine dry red wines won gold medals, 15 won silver and 18 won bronze. That’s 42 medal winners in one category. Absurd.
In some respects, the competition proves the growth in numbers and quality of Missouri wineries. A total of 26 wineries earned ribbons, almost a third of the 91 wine-producers in the state. Stone Hill (Hermann), a perennial powerhouse, took home 28 ribbons, far more than anyone else. My guess is that it had more entries than anyone else, too. Others in double figures were Montelle (Augusta), 17; Augusta (Augusta), 16; Adam Puchta (Hermann), 14; and St. James (St. James), 11.
The rest of the medal-winners includes wineries that are both old and new, from familiar cities and towns and others you’d never expect: They included Blumenhof (Dutzow), 9; Hermannhof (Hermann), 6; Twin Oaks (Farmington),6; Les Bourgeois (Rocheport), 5; Mount Pleasant (Augusta), 5; Cave Vineyards (Ste. Genevieve), 4; Baltimore Bend (Waverly), 4; Native Stone (Jefferson City), 3; Stone Haus (Lee’s Summit), 3; Traver Home (Willow Springs), Durso Hills (Marquand), Chandler Hill (Defiance), Sugar Creek (Defiance), and Jowler’s Creek (Platte City), 2 each; Chaumette (Ste. Genevieve), Hemman (Brazeau), Cooper’s Oak (Higbee), Inland Sea (Kansas City), Meramec Vineyards (St. James), Peaceful Bend (Steelville) and Bommarito (New Haven), 1 each.
Why so many medals? The laws of Commerce, I guess, and I’m sure winemakers and owners want lots of medals to display. If it were my choice, I’d have more classes of competition, with gold, silver and bronze in each category. I’d match Vidal against Vidal, Norton against Norton, rather than lumping all dry reds together, regardless of grape of origin. The organizers did the same thing for semi-dry and sweet wines, both red and white. That’s not quite comparing apples and oranges, but it’s close. I’d also limit wineries to one entry in each class, which would allow a winemaker to enter his best and prevent Stone Hill from entering enough Nortons from various vintages and vineyards to win six gold medals.
And as long as I’m rearranging the state government, I’d then send the show on the road, with a couple of buses emblazoned with banners, taking winemakers and other vineyard representatives around the state for several days, to towns large and small, stopping here and there for tastings and barbecues, letting everyone know that there are 90 wineries in the state, hiring employees and paying taxes and helping the economy.
Tom Uhlenbrock of the Post-Dispatch recently used the front page of a Sunday section for three successive weeks to write about wineries, two weeks for Missouri and one for Illinois, and he could have used another week to write about the new wineries in the western part of the state.
Unfortunately, the wineries don’t seem to care a lot, either. I was at Mount Pleasant last weekend as the winery, one of the nation’s oldest, marked its 150th anniversary. Its Brut Imperial sparkling wine, not only a gold medal winner but a best of class, is a splendid wine, with a wonderful crisp dryness and a nice bubble, but I saw no acknowledgment of its honors. The Governor’s Cup winner, a 2007 Stone Hill Norton from the Cross J Vineyard, also is a glorious wine, rich and flavorful, with smooth plummy flavors and well-deserving of its accolades.
And the winners are. . . .
GOVERNOR’S
CUP: Best of Best in Class, Stone Hill (Hermann) 2007 Cross J Vineyard Norton
BEST
OF CLASS:
Sparkling Wine, Mount Pleasant (Augusta) Brut Imperial
Dry White, Montelle (Augusta) 2008 Chardonel
Semi-Dry White, Montelle 2008 Dry Vignoles
Sweet White, Stone Hill 2008 Vignoles
Dry Red, Stone Hill 2007 Cross J Vineyard Norton
Semi-Dry Red, Augusta Winery (Augusta) Reserve Red
Sweet Red, Adam Puchta Winery (Hermann) Riefenstahler
Blush Wine, Twin Oaks (Farmington) Two Brothers
Late Harvest, Stone Hill 2008 Late Harvest Vignoles
Dessert Wine, Adam Puchta Signature Port
Fruit Wine, St. James Winery (St. James) Strawberry
Distilled Spirit, Montelle Peach Brandy
GOLD
MEDALS:
Sparkling Wine, Mount Pleasant Brut Imperial; Stone Hill Golden Spumante
Dry White, Montelle 08 Chardonel; Montelle 08 Seyval Blanc
Semi-Dry White, Montelle 08 Dry Vignoles; Stone Hill 08 Traminette, Stone Hill 07 Steinberg
Sweet White, Stone Hill 08 Vignoles; Golden Rhine; Stonehaus (Lee’s Summit) Traminette; Augusta 08 Vignoles; Blumenhof (Dutzow) 08 Femme Osage, 08 Vignoles, 08 Valvin Muscat; Les Bourgeois (Rocheport) 08 Vignoles-Traminette
Dry Red, Adam Puchta 05 Norton; Les Bourgeois 07 Premium Claret; Chaumette (Ste. Genevieve) 07 Chambourcin; Stone Hill 07 Chambourcin; Stone Hill 05 Cross J Norton; Stone Hill 07 Cross J Norton
Semi-Dry Red, Baltimore Bend (Waverly) Last Minute; Les Bourgeois 08 Fleur de Vin
Sweet Red, Montelle Stone House Red; Stone Hill Concord; Adam Puchta Riefenstahler
Blush, Augusta La Fleur Sauvage; Stone Hill Rose Montaigne; Twin Oaks Two Brothers
Late Harvest/Ice Wine, Stone Hill 08 Late Harvest Vignoles; Augusta 08 Ice Wine; Montelle 08 Vidal Ice Wine
Dessert
Wine, St. James 06 Chardonel Dessert Wine; Stone Hill 06 Port, Cream Sherry; Montelle 05 Cynthiana Port; Adam Puchta Signature Port
Fruit Wine, St. James Strawberry
Distilled Spirit, Montelle Peach Brandy
SILVER MEDALS:
Sparkling Wine, Stone Hill 05 Blanc de Blancs
Dry White, Traver Home (Willow Springs) Vignoles; Stone Hill 06 Reserve Chardonel, 07 Chardonel, 08 Chardonel; Augusta 07 Estate Bottled Vidal Blanc; Adam Puchta Vidal
Semi-Dry White, Augusta 08 Seyval Blanc; Hermannhof (Hermann) 07 Vidal Blanc; Montelle River Country White; Blumenhof (Dutzow) 08 Rayon D’Or, 08 Missouri Weinland; Les Bourgeois 08 LaBelle; Stone Hill 08 Steinberg White; Stonehaus Vignoles
Sweet White, Baltimore Bend Sweet Beginnings; St. James 08 Vintner’s Select Vignoles; Augusta River Valley White; Montelle Himmelswein.
Dry Red, Adam Puchta Vintner’s Reserve Norton; Stonehaus Chambourcin; Stone Hill Hermannsberger, 06 Chambourcin, 05 Estate Bottled Norton, 06 Estate Bottled Norton; Cave Vineyard (Ste. Genevieve) 07 Chambourcin, 07 Norton; St. James 08 Chambourcin; Blumenhof 07 Original Cyn; Stone Hill 06 Cross J Norton, 05 Estate Bottled Norton, 06 Estate Bottled Norton; Mount Pleasant Norton, Cabernet Sauvignon; Augusta 06 Estate Bottled Chambourcin, 06 Estate Bottled Norton
Semi-Dry Red, Montelle River Country Red; Stone Hill Steinberg Red
Sweet Red, St. James Country Red; Durso Hills (Marquand) Durso Red
Blush, Adam Puchta Rose; Montelle La Rosee; Cave Vineyards Grotta Rossa; Les Bourgeois Pink Fox; Stone Hill Spumante Blush, Pink Catawba
Dessert Wine, Native Stone (Jefferson City) Norton Port; Stone Hill 05 Port; Augusta 05 Vintage Port; St. James 05 Norton Dessert Wine
Fruit Wine, Augusta Blackberry, Raspberry; Montelle Strawberry; Hemman (Brazeau) Blueberry.
Distilled Spirit, Montelle Grappa Brandy
BRONZE MEDALS:
Dry White, Les Bourgeois 07 Solay; Inland Sea Wines (Kansas City) 08 Chardonnay;
St. James 06 Reserve Chardonel; Augusta 08 Traminette
Semi-Dry White, Hermannhof 08 Traminette, 07 Traminette; Jowler Creek (Platte City) Vignoles; Baltimore Bend Cirrus; Hermannhof 07 Traminette; Native Stone Lewis & Clark’s Sweet Discovery
Sweet White, Adam Puchta Vignoles (American), Vignoles (Missouri), Misty Valley, Adam’s Choice; Hermannhof 08 Vignoles; Peaceful Bend (Steelville) Whittenburg; Augusta 07 Vignoles; Cave Vineyard 08 Traminette; Montelle Stone House White; Twin Oaks Traminette; Blumenhof La Charrette
Dry Red, Twin Oaks Shady Oak, Chambourcin; Chandler Hill (Defiance) 06 Old Brick, 05 Norton Sauvage; Durso Hills 06 Norton; Adam Puchta Estate Bottled Norton, Hunter’s Red; Sugar Creek (Defiance) Chambourcin, Cynthiana; Traver Home Bear’s Den Red; Jowler Creek (Platte City) Chambourcin; Hermannhof 02 Norton; Stone Hill 03 Estate Bottled Norton; St. James 06 Reserve Norton; Augusta 05 Estate Bottled Chambourcin; Montelle 06 Cynthiana; Cooper’s Oak Winery (Higbee) 08 Chambourcin
Sweet Red, Baltimore Bend Arrowhead Red; Augusta River Valley Red; Twin Oaks Murphy’s Settlement; Hermannhof StagsWood Red; Native Stone Captain’s Red; Meramec Vineyards (St. James) New World Red; Blumenhof Devil’s Den Red
Blush, Blumenhof 08 Winegarden Rose; Stone Hill Dry Rose
Late Harvest, St. James 05 Late Harvest Chardonel
Dessert Wine, Bommarito Estate (New Haven) 04 Red Missouri Port; Twin Oaks Royal Ruby; Mount Pleasant Tawny Port, Vintage Port; Adam Puchta Anniversary Port
Fruit Wine, Adam Puchta Berry Black
Distilled Spirit, Montelle Pear Brandy
Judges:
Joyce Angelos, Kansas City; Glenn Bardgett, St. Louis; Jill Blume, Purdue, Ind.; Jean Burgess, Clermont, Fla.; Rene Chazottes, Los Angeles; John Damian, Watkins Glen, N.Y.; Bob Foster, San Diego; Doug Frost, Kansas City; Michelle Meyer, Basehor, Kan.; David Peterson, Romulus, N.Y.; Guy Stout, Houston; Chris West, Macon, Mo.
-Joe
Recent Comments